Ethics Approval and Informed Consent: What Journals Expect in Your Manuscript

Ethics approval and informed consent are critical components of responsible research and essential requirements for most journal submissions. This article explains what journals expect in an ethics approval statement, how informed consent should be reported, and provides examples aligned with common publisher requirements from Springer, Elsevier, and other leading journals.

Updated on November 18, 2026

Ethics Approval

Research involving human participants, personal data, human tissues, or animals carries ethical responsibilities that extend far beyond study design and data collection. Before a manuscript can be published, journals increasingly require authors to clearly document how ethical requirements were met.

Missing or incomplete ethics information is one of the most common reasons manuscripts are delayed during peer review or returned to authors before editorial assessment. To demonstrate compliance with publication standards, researchers must typically provide an ethics approval statement and, where applicable, information about informed consent.

This article explains what journals expect, how ethics approval and informed consent differ, and how to write clear ethical statements that meet publisher requirements.

Why Ethics Statements Matter

Ethics statements demonstrate that research was conducted responsibly and in accordance with recognized ethical standards.

Journals request these statements to ensure that:

  • Participant rights were protected
  • Risks were appropriately managed
  • Ethical review was completed when required
  • Personal data were handled responsibly
  • Research complies with institutional and regulatory requirements
  • Readers can assess the ethical integrity of the study

Most major publishers, including Elsevier, Springer Nature, Wiley, Taylor & Francis, and SAGE, require ethical disclosures as part of manuscript submission.

Ethics Approval vs. Informed Consent: What's the Difference?

Although the terms are often mentioned together, ethics approval and informed consent are not the same thing.

Many manuscripts require both.

For example, a clinical survey study typically receives ethics approval from an Institutional Review Board (IRB) and obtains informed consent from each participant before data collection begins.

What Is an Ethics Approval Statement?

An ethics approval statement is a section within a manuscript that explains whether ethical review was conducted and identifies the approving body.

Editors and reviewers often look for this information before assessing the scientific content of a submission.

A typical ethics approval statement includes:

  • Name of the ethics committee or IRB
  • Institution responsible for approval
  • Approval or protocol number (if available)
  • Confirmation that approval was obtained before research began
  • Statement that procedures complied with relevant guidelines

Ethics Approval Statement Example

Researchers frequently search for an ethical approval statement example when preparing a manuscript.

A general example might read:

"This study was approved by the Institutional Review Board of XYZ University (Approval No. 2026-145). All procedures involving human participants were performed in accordance with the ethical standards of the institutional research committee and the principles of the Declaration of Helsinki."

The exact wording may vary by journal and study type, but transparency and specificity are essential.

When Is Ethics Approval Required?

Ethics approval is commonly required for research involving:

Human Participants

Examples include:

  • Clinical trials
  • Surveys and questionnaires
  • Interviews and focus groups
  • Behavioral studies
  • Educational research involving participants

Human Data or Biological Samples

Examples include:

  • Medical records
  • Patient databases
  • Tissue samples
  • Genomic information

Animal Studies

Research involving animals typically requires review by an institutional animal care and use committee and adherence to relevant welfare standards.

When Might Ethics Approval Not Be Required?

Some research may be exempt from formal ethics review, depending on institutional and national regulations.

Examples sometimes include:

  • Publicly available anonymized datasets
  • Literature reviews
  • Systematic reviews
  • Meta-analyses
  • Certain educational quality-improvement projects

However, journals may still require authors to explain why ethics approval was not necessary.

A statement such as the following may be appropriate when permitted by institutional policies:

"Ethical approval was not required for this study because it involved analysis of publicly available, anonymized data and did not involve interaction with human participants."

Researchers should always verify requirements with their institution and target journal before submission.

What Is Informed Consent?

Informed consent is the process through which participants voluntarily agree to participate after receiving sufficient information about the research.

Participants should understand:

  • The purpose of the study
  • What participation involves
  • Potential risks and benefits
  • Privacy and confidentiality protections
  • Their right to withdraw

An informed consent statement reassures journals that participant rights were respected throughout the research process.

What Do Journals Expect Regarding Informed Consent?

For manuscripts involving human participants, journals generally expect authors to state whether informed consent was obtained.

A common statement might read:

"Written informed consent was obtained from all participants prior to enrollment in the study."

For studies involving children, patients, photographs, case reports, or identifiable information, journals often require additional confirmation that publication consent was also obtained.

This requirement is particularly important for clinical case reports and patient-based research.

Informed Consent in Journal Articles

Many researchers reviewing informed consent journal articles notice that publishers use similar wording across disciplines.

Common examples include:

  • Written informed consent was obtained from all participants.
  • Electronic informed consent was obtained before participation.
  • Informed consent was waived by the ethics committee due to the retrospective design of the study.
  • Participant data were anonymized and informed consent requirements were waived by the review board.

The key principle is that journals expect authors to clearly explain how participant autonomy and privacy were protected.

Common Mistakes Authors Make

Even experienced researchers occasionally encounter ethical reporting issues during peer review.

Common problems include:

Missing Ethics Approval Information: Authors may state that approval was obtained but fail to identify the approving committee.

Missing Approval Numbers: Many journals request protocol or approval numbers when available.

Incomplete Informed Consent Statements: Simply stating that participants were recruited may not adequately document the consent process.

Confusing Consent With Ethics Approval: Obtaining participant consent does not replace institutional ethical review requirements.

Omitting Exemption Explanations: If ethics approval was not required, journals usually expect a justification.

Where Should Ethics Statements Appear?

The placement depends on journal requirements.

Common locations include:

  • Methods section
  • Ethics declarations section
  • Submission system ethics fields
  • Supplementary materials

To avoid delays, ensure that ethics information is included both in the manuscript and anywhere requested during electronic submission.

A Simple Ethics Statement Template

Researchers can adapt the following template to their study:

"Ethics approval for this study was obtained from [Committee Name] at [Institution] (Approval No. XXXX). All procedures involving human participants were conducted in accordance with institutional guidelines and the Declaration of Helsinki. Written informed consent was obtained from all participants prior to participation."

For studies where consent was waived:

"Ethics approval was granted by [Committee Name] (Approval No. XXXX). The requirement for informed consent was waived by the ethics committee because anonymized retrospective data were analyzed."

Always modify templates to reflect the actual study procedures and journal requirements.

Final Thoughts

A well-written ethics section demonstrates research integrity and helps journals evaluate compliance with publication standards. Whether you are preparing a clinical study, survey research, observational investigation, or animal study, clear reporting of ethics approval and informed consent is essential.

Including a complete ethics approval statement, documenting informed consent procedures, and following journal-specific requirements can reduce editorial delays, strengthen reviewer confidence, and improve the likelihood of successful publication.

Contributors
Tag
Table of contents
Share+
FacebookTwitterLinkedInCopy linkEmail
Join the newsletter
Sign up for early access to AJE Scholar articles, discounts on AJE services, and more

See our "Privacy Policy"